Pinned
Top 16 Tournament, Round 1 Breakdown
Round 1 is in the history books. It was the first tournament round on RocBattle 5.0, and here's the breakdown: staff votes, community votes, why someone won or lost, and why someone could have more votes and still lose.
How it works
Every tournament battle has two sides voting: the community and the staff judges.
- Community votes count for 70% of the result.
- Staff votes count for 30%.
- If no staff voted, the community counts for 100%.
So you're battling for both sides. Win the community big and you're usually safe. If the community is close and the staff all go the other way, the staff side can flip it. That happened twice this round.
Blowouts: tournament battles normally wait for the staff judges before they close. But when one producer leads by 15 or more votes, that's a blowout. You can come back from 10 down. 15 down is really hard to come back from, and with a lead that lopsided, the staff's input can't shift it. In situations like that, we trust the community. Three battles this round were blowouts, so they closed early.
One more thing: the winner is decided by votes, not points. The MAC scores (Mix, Arrangement, Creativity) below just show where each beat stood out.
The breakdown
1. CMagikBeats def. bigglabel (71% to 29%)
Community 23-16 CMagikBeats. Staff 3-0 CMagikBeats.
Closer than 71% looks. The community rated both beats almost exactly the same (8.40 vs 8.38), and the mix scores were dead even. CMagikBeats edged it on creativity and arrangement, and the staff heard a clear gap. bigglabel came to fight. This one was decided by inches, and CMagikBeats took both sides.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-069b-70c1-ac5f-e3510f562b38
2. 3rd.music def. prod.quan_ (61% to 39%)
Community 19-15 prod.quan_. Staff 4-0 3rd.music.
This is the "more votes and still lost" battle, so here's the math:
- 3rd.music: 44% of the community x 70% = 31, plus 100% of the staff x 30% = 30. Total 61.
- prod.quan_: 56% of the community x 70% = 39, plus 0% of the staff. Total 39.
prod.quan_ had the ideas and the crowd. They scored higher on creativity and arrangement and won the community. But 3rd.music had the cleaner mix, the biggest mix gap of the whole round (7.79 vs 7.08), and every staff judge heard it. Lesson for everybody: you have to win both sides. Great ideas need a mix that holds up.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0784-7349-9da1-e9529c970204
3. DLIVE def. hottroundz (blowout, 19-4)
A 15-vote lead, so it closed early. The mixes were close. The gap was arrangement (8.35 vs 7.35) and creativity (8.57 vs 7.74). DLIVE's beat went somewhere and kept the listener locked in.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-090e-71f8-8810-9cdaa7b575bc
4. BrainGotBlaps def. MurdaBeats (blowout, 22-4)
An 18-vote lead, so it closed early. MurdaBeats' mix actually scored a hair higher (7.96 vs 7.92), so the mix wasn't the problem. Creativity was: 8.65 vs 7.54, the biggest creativity gap of the round. BrainGotBlaps brought the idea people remembered.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0a96-711c-8c86-64ec0e096ec5
5. 9elevenbeats def. SIK_TRAKZ (53% to 47%)
Community 18-11 9elevenbeats. Staff 2-1 SIK_TRAKZ.
One of the closest battles of the round, and a battle of strengths. SIK_TRAKZ had the better arrangement and a slight edge on creativity, and the staff leaned their way. 9elevenbeats had the much stronger mix (8.34 vs 7.19), and the community went with it. The community lead was big enough to hold. If all 3 staff had gone SIK_TRAKZ, it flips. That's how close it was.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0b10-723c-8bed-c4b60ca37908
6. Dirteeworks def. staffmuzik (62% to 38%)
Community 16-11 Dirteeworks. Staff 2-1 Dirteeworks.
Not a lot separating these two on paper. staffmuzik had a slight creativity edge, but Dirteeworks was ahead on mix and arrangement and was the more complete beat. Dirteeworks won both sides.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-240d-7358-8c6d-3873b5fa1b7b
7. AngelicVoicesMinistry def. BosBeats (blowout, 21-5)
A 16-vote lead, so it closed early. AngelicVoicesMinistry led every category, and arrangement was the biggest gap (7.62 vs 6.88).
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c69d-f923-70b1-9b5e-c596be920959
8. ThatsDopeMusic def. jayfontaine_ (52% to 48%)
Community 18-15 jayfontaine_. Staff 2-1 ThatsDopeMusic.
The closest battle of the round, and the second "more votes and still lost." Here's the math:
- ThatsDopeMusic: 45% of the community x 70% = 32, plus 67% of the staff x 30% = 20. Total 52.
- jayfontaine_: 55% of the community x 70% = 38, plus 33% of the staff x 30% = 10. Total 48.
jayfontaine_ had the edge with voters on the MAC, especially the mix (7.72 vs 7.31). But the community was only 3 votes apart, and when it's that close, the staff side decides it. 2 of the 3 staff judges went with ThatsDopeMusic. One more community vote for ThatsDopeMusic, or one staff vote the other way, and this goes the other way. That's what battling for both sides means.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0896-7382-ab80-05ea964aac95
Congrats to everyone moving on to round 2. To everyone going home: you made the Top 16. Go back, listen to your battle and read the comments.
Best regards,
Fat Fingers
How it works
Every tournament battle has two sides voting: the community and the staff judges.
- Community votes count for 70% of the result.
- Staff votes count for 30%.
- If no staff voted, the community counts for 100%.
So you're battling for both sides. Win the community big and you're usually safe. If the community is close and the staff all go the other way, the staff side can flip it. That happened twice this round.
Blowouts: tournament battles normally wait for the staff judges before they close. But when one producer leads by 15 or more votes, that's a blowout. You can come back from 10 down. 15 down is really hard to come back from, and with a lead that lopsided, the staff's input can't shift it. In situations like that, we trust the community. Three battles this round were blowouts, so they closed early.
One more thing: the winner is decided by votes, not points. The MAC scores (Mix, Arrangement, Creativity) below just show where each beat stood out.
The breakdown
1. CMagikBeats def. bigglabel (71% to 29%)
Community 23-16 CMagikBeats. Staff 3-0 CMagikBeats.
Closer than 71% looks. The community rated both beats almost exactly the same (8.40 vs 8.38), and the mix scores were dead even. CMagikBeats edged it on creativity and arrangement, and the staff heard a clear gap. bigglabel came to fight. This one was decided by inches, and CMagikBeats took both sides.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-069b-70c1-ac5f-e3510f562b38
2. 3rd.music def. prod.quan_ (61% to 39%)
Community 19-15 prod.quan_. Staff 4-0 3rd.music.
This is the "more votes and still lost" battle, so here's the math:
- 3rd.music: 44% of the community x 70% = 31, plus 100% of the staff x 30% = 30. Total 61.
- prod.quan_: 56% of the community x 70% = 39, plus 0% of the staff. Total 39.
prod.quan_ had the ideas and the crowd. They scored higher on creativity and arrangement and won the community. But 3rd.music had the cleaner mix, the biggest mix gap of the whole round (7.79 vs 7.08), and every staff judge heard it. Lesson for everybody: you have to win both sides. Great ideas need a mix that holds up.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0784-7349-9da1-e9529c970204
3. DLIVE def. hottroundz (blowout, 19-4)
A 15-vote lead, so it closed early. The mixes were close. The gap was arrangement (8.35 vs 7.35) and creativity (8.57 vs 7.74). DLIVE's beat went somewhere and kept the listener locked in.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-090e-71f8-8810-9cdaa7b575bc
4. BrainGotBlaps def. MurdaBeats (blowout, 22-4)
An 18-vote lead, so it closed early. MurdaBeats' mix actually scored a hair higher (7.96 vs 7.92), so the mix wasn't the problem. Creativity was: 8.65 vs 7.54, the biggest creativity gap of the round. BrainGotBlaps brought the idea people remembered.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0a96-711c-8c86-64ec0e096ec5
5. 9elevenbeats def. SIK_TRAKZ (53% to 47%)
Community 18-11 9elevenbeats. Staff 2-1 SIK_TRAKZ.
One of the closest battles of the round, and a battle of strengths. SIK_TRAKZ had the better arrangement and a slight edge on creativity, and the staff leaned their way. 9elevenbeats had the much stronger mix (8.34 vs 7.19), and the community went with it. The community lead was big enough to hold. If all 3 staff had gone SIK_TRAKZ, it flips. That's how close it was.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0b10-723c-8bed-c4b60ca37908
6. Dirteeworks def. staffmuzik (62% to 38%)
Community 16-11 Dirteeworks. Staff 2-1 Dirteeworks.
Not a lot separating these two on paper. staffmuzik had a slight creativity edge, but Dirteeworks was ahead on mix and arrangement and was the more complete beat. Dirteeworks won both sides.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-240d-7358-8c6d-3873b5fa1b7b
7. AngelicVoicesMinistry def. BosBeats (blowout, 21-5)
A 16-vote lead, so it closed early. AngelicVoicesMinistry led every category, and arrangement was the biggest gap (7.62 vs 6.88).
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c69d-f923-70b1-9b5e-c596be920959
8. ThatsDopeMusic def. jayfontaine_ (52% to 48%)
Community 18-15 jayfontaine_. Staff 2-1 ThatsDopeMusic.
The closest battle of the round, and the second "more votes and still lost." Here's the math:
- ThatsDopeMusic: 45% of the community x 70% = 32, plus 67% of the staff x 30% = 20. Total 52.
- jayfontaine_: 55% of the community x 70% = 38, plus 33% of the staff x 30% = 10. Total 48.
jayfontaine_ had the edge with voters on the MAC, especially the mix (7.72 vs 7.31). But the community was only 3 votes apart, and when it's that close, the staff side decides it. 2 of the 3 staff judges went with ThatsDopeMusic. One more community vote for ThatsDopeMusic, or one staff vote the other way, and this goes the other way. That's what battling for both sides means.
https://rocbattle.com/battles/01a1c667-0896-7382-ab80-05ea964aac95
Congrats to everyone moving on to round 2. To everyone going home: you made the Top 16. Go back, listen to your battle and read the comments.
Best regards,
Fat Fingers
